I Scrap Alone

Last Wednesday, I finished up talking about the methods I used in my dissertation. Today, I am going to start talking about my findings.

I Scrap Alone
Scrapbookers rarely acknowledge the help they receive with their scrapbooking. I’m guilty of this, too and scrapbooking is not much different from anything else we do in this regard. Most scrapbooks are thought of as being created by an individual most of the time. By talking about the ways in which scrapbookers are helped in their scrapbooking, it is possible to learn not only how scrapbookers are helped but also where scrapbooking norms come.

Respondents rarely acknowledge receiving help scrapbooking when asked directly, but they did mention throughout the interview how others help them (e.g., posing for photographs). My respondents interpreted the question as if I were asking if they had help in creating the actual scrapbook page, rather than did they get help before the construction of the page. Sometimes their friend or family member that I also interviewed talked about how they had helped the scrapbooker even after the scrapbooker had insisted they never had help.

Scrapbookers receive help in their scrapbooking in several ways. Husbands watch children so their wives can scrapbook. Family members, friends, and children‟s teachers email digital photographs to parents and send printed photographs home with children for their parents. Others take photographs for the scrapbooker so that the scrapbooker’s image can be in the scrapbook. Some of these people work on improving their photography skills for the benefit of the scrapbooker. Family and friends consent to have their photograph taken for the scrapbook. Family members provide financial resources so the scrapbooker can buy supplies (most often husbands but also parents of college-aged scrapbookers). Family members also purchase scrapbook supplies as gifts for the scrapbooker or ship supplies across the country that the scrapbooker can not find locally. Children (and others) save mementos for the scrapbook (e.g., art projects or programs). Scrapbookers find support through receiving general encouragement (e.g., “can I see your scrapbook?”) and when partners and children go shopping with them for scrapbooking supplies. Scrapbookers more actively solicit help in some instances. They ask others to write journaling or corroborate their memory for their journaling, label photographs for the scrapbook, and proofread journaling. Though rare, the scrapbooker may have someone else complete a page for their album. At crops, scrapbookers often ask for input from scrapbooking peers for ideas or techniques to use on their own pages. In other words, most scrapbookers do receive some form of help—some more than others—with their scrapbooking. Help from others is also done in more recognizable ways: through reading books and magazines about scrapbooking, using the internet for scrapbooking tips, watching scrapbooking television shows, and taking classes on scrapbooking. Importantly, scrapbookers insist, by and large, that they do not get help from others even when they obviously do receive some help.

Do you receive any help scrapbooking? Are their other ways you are helped that I did not mention above? Comment below.

Share
Posted in Dissertation, Findings, Scrapbook Norms | Tagged , | Comments Off on I Scrap Alone

It’s Always Sunny?

The topic of inequality in the scrapbook industry is one that I address in my dissertation and I will have much more to say on the matter once I reach those sections of my dissertation in my Wednesday posts. A video that came across my desk Friday,however, has made this discussion more urgent. At the risk of alienating myself from the entire scrapbook industry, here it goes:

The video is from scrapbook.com and is called It’s Always Sunny in Here. I have watched it twice. It is quite clever, cute, and entertaining. Nancy Nally of Scrapbook Update describes it best as “a combination of Glee and Mad Men in theme” and she is also correct that this video is a great example of viral marketing. That being said, I think we need to take a closer look at the messages being promoted in this particular advertisement.

Scrapbooking is one of those things white people like
The first time I watched the video, I got about half-way through and thought, “wow, that’s a lot of white people.” Seriously, thank you scrapbook.com for reinforcing the idea that scrapbooking belongs on Christian Lander’s blog, Stuff White People Like. Perhaps this is just the sociologist in me reading more into the video than necessary, but really, the casting director could not find one person of color to include in the video? After all, there were at least 15 people in the video. I think the worst part about the video is that the song in the video begins with “wonderful, colorful Christmas.” Yes, colorful in terms of many shades of cardstock, but clearly not colorful in terms of people. I know very little about scrapbook.com. Perhaps they were relying on family and friends to star in the video and did not really cast for parts. I could just give scrapbook.com the benefit of the doubt but I think this is symptomatic of a problem within the industry as a whole and must be addressed. I have always been frustrated by the fact that most of the scrapbooking celebrities are white and most of the layouts that get published are of white people when I know for a fact that people of color scrapbook, too.

Scrapbooking is your womanly duty
Beyond the issue of no racial diversity in the video, the video also does a really “good” job at promoting the idea that scrapbooking is a domestic task done by women. Yuck! I do not scrapbook out of womanly duty. Perhaps scrapbook.com is trying to be ironic? I don’t really have much else to say in this point at this time, but will come back to the issue of who scrapbooks and why as it relates to domestic duty in later posts.

Share
Posted in Industry, Inequality | Tagged , | Comments Off on It’s Always Sunny?

Win this Tote!

I know, I know…I’m somewhat critical of giveaway happy blogs–I think giveaways are overused and often used in the place of real content. At the risk of being accused of being a hypocrite, let’s have a giveaway. I am trying to increase the number of likes Scrapworthy Lives has on facebook. Once Scrapworthy Lives reaches 150 fans, I’ll draw a name from all the entries on the facebook page. To enter, you must comment on the post about his giveaway on facebook and tell me how you helped spread the word about Scrapworthy Lives. You can find Scrapworthy Lives on facebook by searching for “Scrapworthy Lives” or click the link on the right. For your efforts, you could win this tote:

Win This!

Share
Posted in Giveaway | Tagged | Comments Off on Win this Tote!

Scrap Happy: Organize Traditional Scrapbook Supplies (File Under Boost Energy)

This entry is part 4 of 66 in the series My Scrap Happy Project

This series occurs on Mondays and is my account of my Scrap Happy project inspired by Gretchen Rubin’s The Happiness Project: Or, Why I Spent a Year Trying to Sing in the Morning, Clean My Closets, Fight Right, Read Aristotle, and Generally Have More Fun.

Organize Traditional Scrapbook Supplies
Oh, traditional scrapbook supplies. You are so pretty. Must buy more. The piles of supplies are lovely unless you actually want to get any scrapbooking completed. My organization system is a work in progress because I moved a couple of months ago and am adapting to my new space.

Paper
Paper Storage
I use Advantus Cropper Hopper Vertical Paper Holder, Frost, 12-Inch-by-12-Inch, Advantus Cropper Hopper Dividers 3-Pack, Frost, 12-Inch-by-12-Inch, and Advantus Cropper Hopper Sticker Envelope, 3-Pack, Frost, 12-Inch-by-12-Inch to store my paper. You can buy an Advantus Cropper Hopper Vertical Paper Holder Value Pack, Frost, 12-Inch-by-12-Inch valuepack and I did purchase a valuepack to get started but find buying them individually gets me exactly what I need. All of my paper is stored this way. I have my cardstock sorted by color, size (I have so few 8.5×11 sheets that I store them with my 12×12 sheets), and style (textured, untextured, bling, and colorcore). My pattern paper is transitioning from a storage system that was kind of random to one that is based on brand and theme. The only themes I store separately from brand are seasons, holidays, pet, travel, and baby. I store scraps of paper by color in the sticker envelopes.

Stickers
I use Advantus Cropper Hopper Vertical Paper Holder Value Pack, Frost, 12-Inch-by-12-Inch to store letter stickers by color. Other types of stickers are stored by brand, color, or in a pile of stickers I just don’t know what to do with. Like I said, my system is a work in progress.

Clear Shoe Boxes
Clear Shoe Boxes
I use the clear 13×7.5×4.25 shoe boxes from The Container Store. To get started I bought the case of 20. Since then, I have bought eight more. I use them to organize embellishments by color and I use them to organize some of my smaller tools by type (inks, abc stamps, other stamps, basic punches, border punches, etc.).

Old-Fashioned Canning Jars
Old Fashioned Canning Jars
I use old-fashioned canning jars to store ribbon. I used to store my ribbon in the clear shoe boxes with embellishments of the same color, but my stash of ribbons outgrew this location. I lucked out and got these canning jars from my Grandma. A couple of the lids are missing, so I am on the lookout for more of these types of jars.

Get Organized!
Organizing your traditional scrapbook supplies does not have to be expensive or intimidating. You just have to figure out a system that makes sense to you. Organizing by color, theme, and type of product makes sense to me. Clear storage also makes sense because you can easily see what you have. I store all the above items on built-in bookshelves (they came with the house). I used to store my supplies on a bookshelf I had bought from Wal-Mart. Easy and inexpensive.

Getting organized can be a daunting task but the rewards are well worth it. Once you are organized, it is so much easier to actually scrapbook because you do not have spend time clearing a space to scrapbook or finding your materials. Start small. I did. I started with the embellishments and it took me a few months to gather all the storage materials for the embellishments and paper. Good luck boosting your energy by organizing your traditional scrapbooking supplies!

*I do earn a small commission on purchases made through the Amazon links. I do not earn any commission on The Container Store link.

Share
Posted in Clutter, Scrap Happy, Boost Energy | Tagged , | Comments Off on Scrap Happy: Organize Traditional Scrapbook Supplies (File Under Boost Energy)

Scrapweb December 3, 2010 Edition

*A cute idea for a homemade advent calendar

*Does this sound like you? This holiday season, be sure to get in front of the camera and not just behind the camera.

*Photography tips for Christmas photos here

*One month at a time for December

*Use your stash! Tiare talks about using rub-ons to change things up. I really need to use my rub-ons. They just seem like such a hassle anymore.

*Free digital Hanukkah accents from Creating Keepsakes

Share
Posted in Scrapweb, Digital Scrapbooking | Tagged , | Comments Off on Scrapweb December 3, 2010 Edition

B&B Review: Scrapbook Page Maps by Becky Fleck

This entry is part 5 of 45 in the series Books & Blogs Review

I have heard a lot of buzz recently about Becky Fleck’s Scrapbook Page Maps. I was completely unfamiliar since I haven’t worked in a local scrapbook store for a couple years, I don’t pay much attention to the scrapbook idea books that do get published. I was at my local scrapbook store a couple of weeks ago and picked up a copy of Scrapbook Page Maps (2008). Of course, most of the recent buzz is that there is now a Scrapbook Page Maps 2 (2010). I figured I should read and review the original before the sequel, so here it goes.

I really don’t have any experience with sketches. I don’t sketch. I don’t follow sketches. I don’t understand their purpose. Fleck begins with an introduction about how to use sketches. Finally, I get why people sketch and use sketches. I’m not so sure I’ll begin using them, but I do understand their purpose now. In a nutshell, sketches are like recipes.

What I like about Scrapbook Page Maps:
*This book is spiral bound so that it can lay flat. What would be even better if it were completely spiral bound, so I could flip the pages completely around if I wanted.
*The back of the book contains punch out cards of every sketch in the book. The purpose is that you can carry the cards with you to a crop or to shop, which is much easier than dragging the book with you.
*Many of the pages contain tips about scrapbooking techniques in general in addition to the sketch
*The book contains both 8.5×11 and 12×12 layouts with instructions on how to convert some of the sketches from one size to another and how to convert the sketch to a card
*There are plenty of single-page and double-page sketches to fit your needs
*The book uses both traditional and digital scrapbook pages to illustrate how to use various sketches

I would like to see:
*More sketches using at least one and more than one 4×6 photograph(s). Not all scrapbookers have the time/desire/money/skill to edit photos to the perfect size for a layout. They have 4×6 photos. Some can be cropped after the fact, but not all. In my own scrapbooking, I edit and crop before I print, which means I rarely crop photos after they have printed. Most of my photos are 4×6 and will remain 4×6.
*All the pages in the book arranged in the same way. In other words, the sketch should be in the same place on every page. I liked to read the sketch first but it was not always in the same location.
*Some discussion on acid-free elements. There is a lot of debate among scrapbookers among using acid-free materials. I prefer acid-free. If I’m just using anything, then I do not need expensive acid-free supplies but can stick with construction paper and other scraps of paper I already have in my house. Some of the pages included things like hemp and tissue paper. I have no idea on if these items are archival. I think that books on scrapbooking need to state their philosophy on acid-free in their introduction so that readers know if the materials are acid-free or not.
*More explanation about how you go from sketch to layout. Some of the layouts did not look anything like the sketch IMHO. A step-by-step explanation with photos would be lovely.

My biggest problem:
Fleck talks a lot about being a scrapbooking rebel, yet discourages gender nonconformity in her book, which lines up neatly with much of the scrapbooking industry. For instance, on page 45,

At first glance, this sketch appears quite girly [it contains flowers and swirls], but with a bit of swapping and replacing, it quickly morphs into a masculine layout.

This may be my own personal issue in that I hate the enforcement of gender norms via scrapbooking products (and otherwise). I have put back stickers about dogs on a number of occasions after seeing “man’s best friend” as one of the stickers. I just don’t understand why it has to be explained how to make a page more girly or less girly or more masculine or less masculine and so forth. People are still going to know that my daughter is a girl even if her scrapbook is blue. This is a topic that will come up again in a future post, so I won’t go into any more depth here.

The best part:
The index is great. You can quickly fine sketches based on the number of photos you have or the type of layout you want to complete (e.g., 12×12 single layout).

Overall:
If you like to use sketches, you will probably really enjoy Scrapbook Page Maps: Sketches For Creative Layouts. If don’t already use sketches, you probably will not get a whole lot out of the book. You will get layout ideas for sure, but you can also get layout ideas for free online. There were not enough extra tips to warrant purchasing the book for that reason.

Share
Posted in B&B Review | Tagged | Comments Off on B&B Review: Scrapbook Page Maps by Becky Fleck

My Dissertation’s Methods: Interviews

It’s been a couple of weeks, since I last posted information directly about my dissertation. In previous posts, I discussed my sample. Now, I want to tell you a little bit about my methods.

Interviews
I used both in-depth interviewing and photo-elicitation interviewing. During the last portion of each interview, I was shown a selection of scrapbook pages from my respondents. We talked about these pages. Then, if I also was interviewing one of their friends of a family member, I viewed the scrapbook pages with that person and asked them questions about the pages. My basic purpose of this was to see if the person who did not create the scrapbook page could tell me what is going on or not. Was the message the scrapbooker intending being received?

How did respondents select their pages?
I asked my respondents to select 10-15 of their scrapbook pages that they felt were representative of what they scrapbook and 5-10 scrapbook pages that they felt were atypical. I purposefully left “representative” and “atypical” undefined. I ended up being shown about 40 pages from each respondent (anywhere between 1 and 149 scrapbook pages). I ended up viewing 1,493 scrapbook pages (about 2-3 times as many as I anticipated). I did not analyze the scrapbook pages separately from the interview.

Share
Posted in Dissertation, Methods | Tagged | Comments Off on My Dissertation’s Methods: Interviews

Real Simple Lessons for Scrapbookers

In the December 2010 issue of Real Simple, they have an article called “5 Things to Save for Your Kids.” I though the article is very applicable to scrapbookers with or without kids. Please visit the link to the article to read Real Simple’s elaboration on each point. Here I will discuss how you might do this as a scrapbooker.
1. Insignificant objects from significant occasions.
I’m already a big saver of memorabilia. I keep ticket stubs, arm bands, playbills, bags from tourist shop purchases, and more. I don’t believe I’ve ever saved a receipt. That might be interesting. The receipt could be from anything: a trip, an important purchase, or just the groceries (I’ve expanded “significant occasions” to include everyday, mundane occasions).
2. Something mortifying from your childhood.
I have scrapbooked my childhood. Well, I have scrapbooked the photos and memorabilia from my childhood. I have not scrapbooked all of my stories from my childhood. There is one slightly mortifying story of my adventure making friendship bread by myself when I was all of ten-years old. The recipe said “beat by hand.” Well, I stuck my hands right into the bowl. To this day, my parents still mention this story. I didn’t realize that “beat by hand” meant, “stir with a spoon.” I need to create a scrapbook page about this particular moment.
3. Your practical, high-quality household items.
I have quilts that my maternal Grandma made. I have baby blankets from when I was born and when my daughter was born. What I don’t have are scrapbook pages about these items. I began completing that task before my daughter was born. I photographed each of her baby blankets with the intent on labeling each photo with who made it, who it was given to, who used it, and so on. I haven’t got that far yet. But, I do think that in addition to saving high-quality household items for future generations, recording the story behind those items is important, too.
4. Something your descendants can repurpose.
This point flows directly from point 3. Don’t just save the item, but share the stories about how the item has been used. For instance, my parents have this marble topped table in their home. My great-grandparents used to butcher meat on that table. My dad inherited because when he was small he kept running into it and the family said he “earned” it that way. Now it holds family photographs and at Christmas time my mom places a ceramic Christmas village on it that my paternal Grandma made. Not only has the item been passed down, but the stories surrounding the item have been passed down, too.
5. What you wear to work on Monday.
I love scrapbooking the everyday. I like it more than scrapbooking the extraordinary. Saving the clothes you wore to work, is valuable.

Share
Posted in Scrapworthy, Everyday Scrapbooking | Tagged , | Comments Off on Real Simple Lessons for Scrapbookers

Scrap Happy: Back Up Digital Photos (File Under Boost Energy)

This entry is part 3 of 66 in the series My Scrap Happy Project

The first part of my scrapbooking happiness project involves boosting energy. The first way I boosted my energy was by backing up my digital photos. So simple. So easy. Rarely done. I always think, “well, I’ll just have to back them up again in a month, I’ll just wait until then to do it” and then it never gets done.

How you back up your digital photos depends on what you currently have available. I used to just store my digital photos in folders on my desktop with such inconsistent names as: Summer 2006, New York City 2007, Family 2005, December 2007, and so on. I then learned about Creative Memories software called Memory Manager. I now organize and do some basic editing of my digital photos in Memory Manager. I like it because it is easy to use and can be set up to create a shadow copy of all of your photographs. I have been using Memory Manager for about two years and have only once made a shadow copy. I decided it was time. I dug out my external hard drive from our fire-proof safe and tried it out. In the process, I deleted all of my photos…some 8,000 photos. Oops. Or so I thought. I tried recovering as many as I could from the various other folders I save photos to (Memory Manager isn’t perfect or it could be user error, but I have the following types of folders outside of Memory Manager: facebook photos, photos to print, photos to email, photos for this project, photos for that project). I recovered many of them that way and I had just placed an order for prints and had not deleted my camera’s memory card (I only do that once it is full). Worse things have happened. A couple days later, I finally had a chance to call Creative Memories to see if they had a fix. Within one minute all of my photos had been recovered. Well, they were never really gone. I just didn’t know how to use all the buttons in the software program. Anyway, now to back them all up to that external hard drive.

Done. I have decided I need to do this at least three times a year. I have set-up a reminder in Google Calendar to email me when it is time to back-up my photographs. You might want to back your photos up more or less frequently. It depends on how often you take photographs, order prints, and so on.

Some of you may wonder why back your photos up at all. I would be devastated if I lost all my photos. If they are backed up somewhere, then I can get more prints made. Don’t trust whatever service you use to print your photos to safely store digital copies. What if they go out of business? Some of these companies require you to make a purchase every so often in order to maintain copies. In other words, if you want your photos backed up, do it yourself.

Share
Posted in Boost Energy, Clutter, Photography, Scrap Happy | Tagged | Comments Off on Scrap Happy: Back Up Digital Photos (File Under Boost Energy)

Scrapweb November 26, 2010 Edition

There are a lot of people creating blogs that are really like scrapbooks. Debbie Hodge has a post about how to easily convert your blog posts to scrapbook pages.

A free digital template.

Organizing unfinished scrapbooking and craft projects

Strategies for stories without photos

How to take great Christmas tree photos

Share
Posted in Scrapweb, Photography, Digital Scrapbooking | Tagged , , | Comments Off on Scrapweb November 26, 2010 Edition